Wednesday, 24 September 2008

google prefers that you don't use URL rewrites....

This is quite an interesting turnaround given that a couple of years ago, Google was actually recommending URL rewrites as best practice. For the discussion, take a look a the search engine round table's take.

2 comments:

Stewart said...

The sites that really spring to mind that use/used that sorta stuff are/was many eCommerce sites, but only really as category filters, so I'm not entirely sure whether that "fits".

TBH, I can understand what Google are saying: don't bother beautifying URLs when nobody's actually going to be using them directly and your variables are self-explanatory.

Ie, various forms (eg searches) probably shouldn't be beautified to the extent a spider cannot figure them out, but non-dynamic document URLs probably should be (eg paths to articles).

Interesting take on it all though: are we (as developers) all slaves to the search engine(s)? :)

Ian said...

So does this basically mean we have to decide between user accessability and Google's?

How do other search engines respond to rewrites?